Fair Dinkum Legal is a document preparation platform, not a law firm. This information is general in nature and does not constitute legal advice.
Read full disclaimer →Australian Parenting Law — General Information
What Does Best Interests of the Child Mean?
“Best interests” is the phrase every parenting order turns on. Since the May 2024 amendments, the statutory list looks different from the old dual-primary test many articles still describe.
Short Answer
Under s 60CA of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth), the court must regard the best interests of the child as the paramount consideration when making a parenting order. Section 60CC sets out how best interests are determined: general considerations in s 60CC(2) (including safety at paragraph (a)), mandatory family violence history and order considerations in s 60CC(2A), additional matters for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander children in s 60CC(3), and how consent orders are treated in s 60CC(4). This is a single integrated inquiry — not the former dual-primary structure that treated “protection from harm” and “meaningful relationship” as separate co-primary considerations.
The Legal Position
Parents hear “best interests” at mediation, in court forms, and in the other party's affidavit. It is easy to assume the phrase hides a simple rule — usually summarised online as “safety first, then relationship.” Current statute is more structured and no longer uses the old dual-primary headings. This guide walks through s 60CA and each operative paragraph of s 60CC you are likely to meet in a parenting case, how Full Court authority treats risk versus proof, and why outdated language in templates can mislead your preparation.
1. s 60CA — best interests are paramount
Section 60CA of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) is the anchor: when a court makes a parenting order, it must regard the best interests of the child as the paramount consideration.
“Paramount” means the best-interests assessment drives the result. Other interests — parental convenience, fairness between adults, or litigation tactics — do not outrank the child's welfare under the Act.
Best interests is not a slogan. It is the legal standard applied to every live-with, spend-time, communication, and parental-responsibility order under s 65D.
Every minute of order you propose will be read against s 60CA. The question is always: what arrangement promotes this child's best interests on the evidence?
2. Current s 60CC structure — not the old dual-primary test
Section 60CC explains how the court determines what is in a child's best interests. The Family Law Amendment Act 2023 (Cth), commencing 6 May 2024, restructured this section.
The former framework listed two “primary considerations” — benefit of a meaningful relationship with both parents, and need to protect from harm — followed by “additional considerations.” That dual-primary architecture is no longer the text of the Act.
Current s 60CC centres on s 60CC(2) general considerations (with safety listed first at paragraph (a)), s 60CC(2A) on family violence history and orders, s 60CC(3) for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander children, and s 60CC(4) on consent orders.
Describing “protection from harm” as the sole or co-equal “primary consideration” in the old sense misstates current law. Safety is the first general consideration under s 60CC(2)(a), within one paramount best-interests inquiry under s 60CA.
3. s 60CC(2) — general considerations, including safety first
Section 60CC(2) requires the court to consider the matters set out in its paragraphs. Paragraph (a) asks what arrangements would promote the safety of the child and each person who has care of the child, including safety from being subjected to, or exposed to, family violence, abuse, neglect, or other harm.
The remaining paragraphs in s 60CC(2) cover the child's views, the nature of relationships with parents and others, each parent's capacity to provide for needs, the likely effect of changes, practical difficulty and expense, maturity and background, attitudes to parenting, family violence (also picked up in (2A)), safety more broadly, and other relevant facts.
The court weighs these considerations as a whole under s 60CA. No single paragraph — including (a) — is a mechanical trump card that ignores the rest of the statutory list and the evidence.
4. s 60CC(2A) — family violence history and family violence orders
When the court considers safety under s 60CC(2)(a), s 60CC(2A) requires it to include consideration of:
Any history of family violence, abuse or neglect involving the child or a person caring for the child; and
Any family violence order that applies or has applied to the child or a member of the child's family.
The breadth of “applies or has applied” means current and past state or territory protection orders can be on the table even if made by consent or without admissions — the court still performs its own assessment (Amador at [94]–[96]).
Disclosure duties under ss 60CF–60CG and consistency requirements interact with this paragraph when family violence orders are in force.
- File and disclose relevant family violence orders (ss 60CF, r 2.10 where applicable)
- Distinguish allegation-source material from judicial findings
- Propose practicable safeguards where risk is argued but not finally proved
5. s 60CC(3) — Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander children
For a child who is an Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander person, s 60CC(3) requires the court to consider the child's right to enjoy their culture with others of that culture, the likely impact of any proposed parenting order on that right, and the type of arrangements that would best promote that right.
The court must also consider the views of the child's Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander family and the relevant Indigenous community, and any kinship obligations and child-rearing practices.
This paragraph is a mandatory part of the best-interests assessment for children to whom it applies — not an optional cultural add-on.
6. s 60CC(4) — consent orders and the best-interests check
When parties ask the court to make parenting orders by consent (for example via Application for Consent Orders under rr 10.04–10.05), s 60CC(4) governs how the court treats that proposal.
The court must still regard the child's best interests as paramount under s 60CA. Consent does not bypass the statutory framework — the court may decline to make proposed orders if satisfied they are not in the child's best interests.
For parents negotiating at mediation, the practical point is that a reached agreement still has to be expressed in orders the court can approve, with risk and safety disclosures complete (including r 10.05 material where required).
7. Case law: risk, proof, proportionality, and delay
Allegation, proof, and Briginshaw (Amador; Neat Holdings)
Amador & Amador [2009] FamCAFC 196 at [94]–[96] confirms the family law court must assess evidence of family violence; a protection order does not displace that duty.
Serious factual allegations attract the Briginshaw / Neat Holdings principle: reasonable satisfaction on the balance of probabilities requires evidence whose strength matches the gravity of what is alleged and the consequences of a finding.
Fact-finding versus unacceptable risk (M v M; Isles & Nelissen)
M v M and Isles & Nelissen distinguish whether conduct occurred from whether an arrangement poses unacceptable risk. Interim conservatism while evidence is untested is not the same as a final finding that contact must remain minimal.
Welfare over time and mitigation (Bielen; Dever)
Bielen & Kozma [2022] FedCFamC1A 221 at [30], [55] emphasises immediate, medium, and long-term welfare and whether identified risk can be mitigated before severing a parent-child relationship.
Dever & Serano [2025] FedCFamC1A 202 at [25], [32]–[34] addresses resistance to a parent, conduct of both parents, proportionality of orders, and procedural unfairness where delay stalemates the evidence base.
8. Language traps — dual-primary articles, ESPR, and “meaningful relationship”
- Stating “the primary consideration is protection from harm” as if the old s 60CC dual-primary list still governs — current law uses s 60CC(2) general considerations with safety at (a), within s 60CA.
- Treating “meaningful relationship with both parents” as a standalone primary consideration that must be “balanced against” safety — that framing matches pre-2024 summaries, not the current consolidated list.
- Using repealed equal shared parental responsibility (former s 61DA) or equal-time defaults (former s 65DAA) — repealed 6 May 2024.
- Assuming an IVO or police facts sheet proves the underlying conduct for parenting purposes — allegation is not finding (Amador).
- Framing interim conservatism as a final verdict on the merits — interim and final hearings serve different evidential stages.
- Proposing vague orders (“reasonable time”) that give the court no practicable template to assess under s 60CC(2) practicality paragraphs.
9. Using the best-interests framework in your case — procedural options
Understanding s 60CA and s 60CC helps you choose what to file and how to frame orders. The following are procedural pathways under federal law — options to consider, not personalised directives.
- Map your proposed orders to s 60CC(2): safety and practicable changeover first, then views, relationships, capacity, and effect of change.
- Disclose family violence orders and history accurately for s 60CC(2A) — incomplete disclosure undermines credibility.
- Separate interim from final: at interim, risk and status quo weigh heavily; at final, tested evidence and cross-examination matter.
- Where Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander identity applies, address s 60CC(3) explicitly with appropriate community input where available.
- If agreement is reached, use Consent Orders (rr 10.04–10.05) so the approved minute reflects s 60CC(4) scrutiny.
- If agreement fails, complete s 60I FDR or obtain a certificate / exemption before contested filing where required.
- Build affidavits that tie each contention to dated evidence — the court applies s 60CC to facts, not narratives alone.
How Fair Dinkum Legal can assist
Fair Dinkum Legal is a document automation and case administration service. It is not a law firm and does not provide legal advice or representation.
Our staff and platform help you organise parenting proposals, risk disclosures, and affidavit material aligned with current s 60CA and s 60CC — for mediation, Consent Orders, or contested applications in the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia.
You choose your pathway, and these are your documents — you review, amend, adopt, and file them at your direction. You may seek independent legal advice at any stage.
Key Legislation and Authorities
- Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) — s 60CA (best interests paramount), s 60CC(2) (general considerations), s 60CC(2A) (family violence history and orders), s 60CC(3) (Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander children), s 60CC(4) (consent orders), ss 60CF–60CG (disclosure and consistency with family violence orders), s 64B & s 65D (parenting orders)
- Family Law Amendment Act 2023 (Cth) — restructuring of s 60CC (commencing 6 May 2024)
- Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Family Law) Rules 2021 (Cth) — r 2.04, rr 10.04–10.05
- Amador & Amador [2009] FamCAFC 196 at [94]–[96]
- Briginshaw v Briginshaw [1938] HCA 34; (1938) 60 CLR 336
- Neat Holdings Pty Ltd v Karajan Holdings Pty Ltd [1992] HCA 66; (1992) 110 ALR 449
- M v M [1988] HCA 68; (1988) 166 CLR 69
- Isles & Nelissen [2022] FedCFamC1A 97
- Bielen & Kozma [2022] FedCFamC1A 221 at [30], [55]
- Dever & Serano [2025] FedCFamC1A 202 at [25], [32]–[34]
Watch
Best interests questioned without evidence
Parental rights and child welfare
Safety and harm assessment criteria
What best interests means in court
Child welfare and parental conflict impact
Best interests and both parents relationship
Understanding best interests standard
Breastfeeding and child's best interests
Understanding what courts actually look at helps you prepare the right evidence.
Already know which process you need?
Fair Dinkum Legal is a document preparation platform, not a law firm. This information is general in nature and does not constitute legal advice.
Read full disclaimer →