Fair Dinkum Legal is a document preparation platform, not a law firm. This information is general in nature and does not constitute legal advice.
Read full disclaimer βAustralian Parenting & Family Violence Law β General Information
Can My Ex Stop Me Seeing My Child in Australia?
Being cut off from your children after separation happens fast. Understanding the difference between parental responsibility on paper, the practical veto in real life, and an enforceable court order is critical.
Short Answer
Under s 61C of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth), each parent holds parental responsibility unless displaced by a court order. However, s 61C is not a self-executing, police-enforceable right to spend time on a given day. Where a parent withholds a childβor where a state family violence order (IVO, ADVO, DVO, FVRO) restricts contactβrestoring time requires moving through the legal authority ladder: direct agreement into Consent Orders, Family Dispute Resolution (s 60I), or applying to the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia for enforceable parenting orders (s 65D) or recovery orders (ss 67Q, 67Tβ67V).
The Legal Position
After separation, one parent often retains the children and controls day-to-day contact. That withholding can coincide withβor be reinforced byβstate family violence orders that restrict communication and attendance. Federal law still recognises parental responsibility under s 61C, but without enforceable parenting orders the arrangement on the ground can harden into a status quo that courts weigh heavily at interim hearings. This guide explains the gap between paper rights and practical control, how protection orders operate as a de facto veto, the procedural ladder to enforceable orders, and how Division 11 resolves collisions between state and federal instruments.
1. Parental responsibility (s 61C) vs the practical veto after separation
Under s 61C(1) of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth), each parent of a child who is not 18 has parental responsibility for the child. Under s 61C(2), parental responsibility is not affected by separation. Under s 61C(3), parental responsibility may be altered only by a court order in force (see also s 61D).
The Family Law Amendment Act 2023 (Cth), commencing 6 May 2024, repealed the former s 61DA presumption of equal shared parental responsibility. That repeal did not create an opposite presumption of sole control in one parent and did not repeal s 61C.
While both parents hold parental responsibility in law under s 61C, s 61C is not a self-executing, police-enforceable schedule of physical time. When no operative parenting order under s 64B or s 65D exists, a parent who retains the children exercises practical unilateral control β what operates in practice as a de facto veto or self-executed interim relief. Absent a court order, withholding does not breach s 61C as an offence, and police will generally not intervene without a court order.
Delay is dangerous: every week that unilateral withholding continues without a formal challenge allows that arrangement to harden into the factual status quo and stability baseline argued at an interim hearing.
Section 61C recognises your parental responsibility in law, but only a specific parenting order makes your time with your children enforceable in practice.
2. How family violence orders (IVOs, ADVOs, DVOs, FVROs) operate as a de facto parenting veto
State and territory protection orders β including under the Family Violence Protection Act 2008 (Vic), the Crimes (Domestic and Personal Violence) Act 2007 (NSW), the Domestic and Family Violence Protection Act 2012 (Qld), and the Restraining Orders Act 1997 (WA) β often intersect with separation withholding even when they are not parenting orders.
Standard conditions prohibiting contact, approaching the protected person, or attending a home or school β or family-law exceptions allowing contact only "as agreed in writing" β place an effective veto in the hands of the protected person.
The "as agreed" enforcement trap: if an order permits child contact only as agreed between the parties, that permission is revocable at will. Any uninvited text, email, phone call, or attendance to ask for time or negotiate changeover risks a criminal breach complaint (s 123 Vic, s 14 NSW, s 177 Qld, s 61 WA), converting a parenting dispute into criminal prosecution.
Even where no protection order has yet been made, the credible threat that direct confrontation will trigger a police call or interim order application creates a similar practical barrier.
The exit is not pressing for informal permission in breach of an order, nor assuming that defeating the state order alone restores contact. The available pathway is obtaining a positive, specific, enforceable parenting order β with stated days, times, and neutral or school-based changeover β that police and courts can read as clear legal authority.
3. The escalation ladder of authority: how parenting arrangements become enforceable
Parenting time becomes enforceable only when recorded in an instrument the courts and police can act on. The following rungs are procedural pathways available under federal law β options to consider, not personalised directives.
Rung 1: Direct negotiation β Parenting Plan (s 63C) vs Consent Orders (rr 10.04β10.07, s 65D)
Where communication is lawful and safe and not prohibited by a protection order, parents may negotiate directly or through representatives.
A written Parenting Plan under s 63C is a signed, dated agreement. The court must have regard to the most recent parenting plan under s 65DAB, but a Parenting Plan is not directly enforceable as a court order if one parent stops complying.
Filing an Application for Consent Orders under r 10.04 (with r 10.05 risk and family violence disclosures where applicable, and noting s 60CC(4) regarding consent orders) converts a reached agreement into a binding s 64B / s 65D parenting order carrying statutory compliance obligations under s 65DA.
Rung 2: Family Dispute Resolution (mediation under s 10F & s 60I) β Consent Orders or s 60I(8) Certificate
If direct negotiation fails or is unavailable, the statutory pre-action step under s 60I(7) and r 4.02 is attempting Family Dispute Resolution (FDR) with an accredited FDR practitioner under s 10G.
If agreement is reached in FDR, it may be formalised into Consent Orders rather than left as an informal understanding where enforceability is required. If FDR fails, is refused, or is assessed as unsuitable, the practitioner issues a s 60I(8) certificate.
Rung 3: Contested application to the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (s 65D / ss 67Q, 67Tβ67V)
Once the s 60I gateway is satisfied by certificate under s 60I(8) or court exemption under s 60I(9), a parent may file an Initiating Application seeking interim and final parenting orders under s 65D.
Where a child has been wrongfully removed or withheld, a recovery order defined in s 67Q and made under s 67U on an application under s 67T may be sought, with the child's best interests paramount under s 67V.
The application is accompanied by a mandatory Notice of Child Abuse, Family Violence or Risk (ss 67Z / 67ZBA, r 2.04) and Genuine Steps Certificate (r 4.01).
4. The mediation myth: can you seek mediation (s 60I) when there is a DV order against you?
A widespread misconception is that being named as a respondent on an IVO, ADVO, DVO, or FVRO makes it illegal or impossible to initiate mediation β causing months or years of inaction while unilateral withholding becomes entrenched.
Contacting an accredited Family Dispute Resolution Practitioner under s 10G or a mediation service to request an intake assessment is not contacting the protected person directly. Many state protection orders contain exceptions permitting communications through a lawyer or for statutory family dispute resolution; the FDR service contacts the other party after screening.
Under s 20 of the Family Law (Family Dispute Resolution Practitioners) Regulations 2025 (Cth), the practitioner must assess whether FDR is appropriate, expressly taking into account any history or presence of family violence (s 20(2)(a)). Under s 22, delivery may be structured (for example shuttle mediation by video or phone in separate rooms) where appropriate.
- s 60I(8)(a) β Non-attendance due to refusal or failure of the other party: you initiated FDR, the practitioner invited the other parent, and the other parent refused or failed to attend.
- s 60I(8)(aa) β FDR inappropriate before starting: the practitioner assesses at intake (for example due to the intervention order, power imbalance, or safety concerns) that it would not be appropriate to conduct FDR.
- s 60I(8)(b) β Genuine effort made by all parties: both parties attended and made a genuine effort, but could not resolve all issues.
- s 60I(8)(c) β Lack of genuine effort: both parties attended, but one or both did not make a genuine effort.
- s 60I(8)(d) β FDR became inappropriate after starting: sessions began, but the practitioner determined it was not appropriate to continue.
- s 60I(9) β Court-granted exemption (without a certificate): the court may grant an exemption from filing a certificate where one or more grounds in s 60I(9) exist, including reasonable grounds to believe there has been or is a risk of child abuse or family violence (s 60I(9)(b)), or in circumstances of urgency (s 60I(9)(d)), subject to s 60J information requirements.
A family violence order does not lock you out of the Family Court. Either mediation proceeds (often by shuttle), the other party refuses and you receive a s 60I(8)(a) certificate, the practitioner deems mediation inappropriate and issues a s 60I(8)(aa) certificate, or a s 60I(9) exemption applies β every path opens the gate to file for parenting orders.
5. The Division 11 intersection: how federal parenting orders override inconsistent DV order conditions (ss 68Nβ68S)
The Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) resolves collisions between federal parenting orders and state or territory family violence orders through disclosure duties, safety consistency requirements, and Division 11.
Mandatory disclosure (s 60CF and r 2.10): parties must inform the federal family law court of relevant family violence orders and file a copy under r 2.10.
Safety and consistency duty (s 60CG): in considering what order to make, the court must, so far as consistent with the child's best interests being paramount under s 60CA, ensure the order is consistent with any family violence order and does not expose a person to an unacceptable risk of family violence (s 60CG(1)), and may include necessary safeguards (s 60CG(2)).
Federal parenting orders prevailing over inconsistent FVO conditions (ss 68Pβ68Q)
Where a federal family law court makes a parenting order (s 65D), recovery order (s 67Q / s 67U), or injunction that provides for a child to spend time with a person (or expressly or impliedly requires or authorises a person to spend time with a child) and that order is inconsistent with an existing state or territory family violence order, s 68P requires the court to specify the inconsistency in the order, give a detailed explanation of how contact is to take place (s 68P(2)(a)β(b)), explain the order and reasons, and serve copies on the state court registrar and police commissioner within 14 days (s 68P(3)).
Under s 68Q(1), to the extent of that spend-time inconsistency, the state family violence order is invalid.
Sections 68Pβ68Q operate subject to their statutory preconditions and only to the extent of the specific spend-time inconsistency. They do not invalidate the rest of the protection order (such as prohibitions on assaulting, harassing, or attending the protected person's residence outside stated changeover terms).
State court power to vary or suspend federal parenting orders (ss 68Rβ68S)
Section 68R operates in the opposite direction: in state or territory proceedings to make or vary a family violence order, the state court has power under s 68R(1) to revive, vary, discharge, or suspend an existing federal spend-time parenting order, recovery order, or arrangement.
Section 68R(3) imposes strict limits: the state court must not do so unless it also makes or varies a family violence order and has before it material that was not before the family law court when the parenting order was made. Under s 68R(4), a state court cannot discharge a federal parenting order when making an interim family violence order (and s 68S governs how the Act and Rules apply when s 68R is exercised).
6. Why DV orders, breaches, criminal charges, and convictions carry heavy weight in Family Court
Under s 60CC(2)(a), the first general consideration in determining a child's best interests (s 60CA) is what arrangements would promote the safety of the child and each person who has care of the child, including safety from being subjected to, or exposed to, family violence, abuse, neglect, or other harm.
Under s 60CC(2A), in considering safety under s 60CC(2)(a), the court must include consideration of: (a) any history of family violence, abuse or neglect involving the child or a person caring for the child; and (b) any family violence order that applies or has applied to the child or a member of the child's family.
Section 60CC(2A)(b) ("applies or has applied") is consequential: the statute requires the court to consider the existence of a current or past family violence order, and on the face of the paragraph does not automatically distinguish between an order made after a contested hearing, an interim order, or an order consented to without admissions.
Breaches (s 123 Vic, s 14 NSW, s 177 Qld, s 61 WA), criminal charges, and convictions add substantial adverse weight. Under ss 67ZBDβ67ZBE, the federal court can issue information-sharing orders to state police and child protection agencies, bringing police attendance records, breach charges, and criminal histories into the family law file.
Under Part XI Division 4 (s 102NL(1)), the strict rules of evidence (such as hearsay) do not apply by default in child-related proceedings, and the court may give admitted material such weight as it thinks fit (s 102NL(2)).
While an untested charge or police narrative is not a conviction or a judicial finding of fact, a breach of an intervention order β even sending frustrated text messages asking to see the children when contact is prohibited β provides concrete evidence of non-compliance with court orders, which weighs heavily against interim unsupervised time.
7. What the case law says: allegations, findings of fact, unacceptable risk, and proportionality
Allegation is not finding, and an IVO is not a substitute for the Family Court's assessment (Amador, Briginshaw & Neat Holdings)
In Amador & Amador [2009] FamCAFC 196 at [94]β[96], the Full Court confirmed that where allegations of domestic violence are relevant to parenting orders under s 60CC, the family law court must assess the evidence before it; the making (or refusal) of a state protection order does not relieve the family court of its own function.
Where a court is asked to make a positive finding that serious family violence or abuse occurred, the standard of proof remains the civil balance of probabilities (s 140 Evidence Act 1995 (Cth)), but as explained in Briginshaw v Briginshaw [1938] HCA 34; (1938) 60 CLR 336 and Neat Holdings Pty Ltd v Karajan Holdings Pty Ltd [1992] HCA 66; (1992) 110 ALR 449; (1992) 67 ALJR 170, the strength and cogency of the evidence required to reach reasonable satisfaction must match the gravity of the allegation and the seriousness of its consequences.
Fact-finding vs 'unacceptable risk' (M v M & Isles & Nelissen)
In M v M [1988] HCA 68; (1988) 166 CLR 69 and Isles & Nelissen [2022] FedCFamC1A 97, the courts distinguish between a positive finding that past abuse occurred (which requires proof on the balance of probabilities) and the prospective assessment of whether an arrangement poses an unacceptable risk of harm.
Even where a court cannot make a positive finding of past conduct β especially at an interim hearing where contested affidavit evidence is not yet cross-examined β it must still assess risk. Challenging the weight (s 102NL(2)) of uncorroborated assertions with objective, dated records and proposing practical safeguards remains essential.
Proportionality, risk mitigation, and status-quo delay (Bielen & Kozma, Dever & Serano)
In Bielen & Kozma [2022] FedCFamC1A 221 at [30], [55], the Full Court emphasised that assessing a child's welfare requires considering the immediate, medium, and long-term impact of proposed orders on the child's safety and wellbeing, and that even where risk is identified, the court must consider whether that risk can be mitigated by practicable safeguards rather than severing the parent-child relationship.
In Dever & Serano [2025] FedCFamC1A 202 at [25], [32]β[34], the Full Court confirmed that where a child's resistance to a parent or a change of residence is in issue, the court must examine the conduct of both parents and the proportionality of the proposed orders, and recognised that excessive delay in determining parenting disputes can produce procedural unfairness under s 60CC.
8. Practical traps that destroy a father's position when children are withheld
- Breaching an IVO/ADVO/DVO/FVRO out of frustration: sending repeated texts, emails, or turning up at the house or school when prohibited β turning a civil parenting dispute into a criminal breach charge (s 123 Vic, s 14 NSW, s 177 Qld, s 61 WA).
- Believing you cannot start s 60I mediation because an IVO exists: waiting until the order expires before contacting an FDR practitioner, allowing unilateral withholding to harden into the status quo.
- Relying on an informal text agreement or s 63C Parenting Plan when compliance is already failing: only a sealed s 65D parenting order (by consent under r 10.04 or after contested application) is legally enforceable.
- Consenting to broad protection-order conditions covering the children without checking ss 68Pβ68R: accepting conditions that prohibit approaching schools, childcare, or the children without workable family-law exceptions.
- Drafting vague orders ("time as agreed"): if the other parent does not agree, you still have zero enforceable time. Orders should state specific days, start/finish times, and a neutral or school changeover location.
- Self-help removal when orders or safety restrictions are in place: taking a child in breach of an existing parenting order or protection order can trigger an urgent s 67U recovery order against you and criminal prosecution.
- Filing emotional narratives instead of dated, evidence-bridged affidavits: courts act on specific dates, exhibited communications, and practicable orders sought β not generalised venting.
9. Step-by-step action plan when you are stopped from seeing your child
- Check your legal baseline immediately: identify whether any federal parenting order (s 64B / s 65D) or state protection order (FVIO, ADVO, DVO, FVRO) is currently in force, and read every condition word for word.
- Zero-breach discipline: if a protection order restricts contact or attendance, comply strictly with its terms β never hand the other party a criminal breach charge (s 123 Vic, s 14 NSW, s 177 Qld, s 61 WA).
- Preserve your evidentiary record: export and back up all SMS, email, and parenting-app messages, care calendars, school/daycare records, and dated notes of every withheld contact event.
- If direct communication is lawful and safe, make a calm, brief written proposal for specific interim parenting time and neutral or school-based changeover; if agreed, formalise it into Application for Consent Orders (r 10.04) rather than relying on an unenforceable arrangement.
- Initiate Family Dispute Resolution (s 60I) promptly through an accredited FDR practitioner (s 10G) β even if an IVO/ADVO/DVO is in force β so you either reach agreement in shuttle mediation or obtain a s 60I(8)(a) or s 60I(8)(aa) certificate.
- Assess whether a s 60I(9) exemption applies (such as urgency under s 60I(9)(d) or family violence / child abuse risk under s 60I(9)(b)), particularly where an urgent recovery order (ss 67Q, 67Tβ67V) is required.
- Prepare your Federal Circuit and Family Court Initiating Application pack: minute of proposed interim and final orders (with specific days, times, and neutral changeover), supporting affidavit, Notice of Child Abuse, Family Violence or Risk (r 2.04), and Genuine Steps Certificate (r 4.01).
- Where an existing state protection order conflicts with proposed parenting time, address Division 11 (ss 68Pβ68Q) and file the protection order under r 2.10 so the federal court can frame orders that prevail to the extent of the spend-time inconsistency.
- Contest or seek variation of parallel state protection-order conditions on the state track (including s 68R considerations where applicable) so the state and federal tracks do not undercut each other.
How Fair Dinkum Legal can assist
Fair Dinkum Legal is a document automation and case administration service. It is not a law firm and does not provide legal advice or representation.
Whether you are preparing for Family Dispute Resolution (s 60I), formalising Consent Orders, defending a state protection order, or preparing an Initiating Application, Notice of Risk, and supporting affidavit for the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia, our staff and platform help you organise your timeline, evidence, and procedural options.
You choose your pathway, and these are your documents β you review, amend, adopt, and file them at your direction. You may seek independent legal advice at any stage.
Key Legislation and Authorities
- Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) β s 60CA (best interests paramount), s 60CC(2)β(2A) & s 60CC(4) (best interests considerations, family violence history/orders, and consent orders), ss 60CFβ60CG (disclosure of family violence orders and unacceptable risk), s 60I & s 60J (family dispute resolution certificates and exemptions), s 61C & s 61D (parental responsibility), s 63C & s 65DAB (parenting plans), s 64B & s 65D (parenting orders), ss 67Q, 67Tβ67V (recovery orders), ss 67Zβ67ZBB & ss 67ZBDβ67ZBE (notices of risk and information sharing), ss 68N, 68P, 68Q, 68R, 68S (Division 11 β inconsistent family violence orders), ss 102NLβ102NM (evidence in child-related proceedings)
- Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Family Law) Rules 2021 (Cth) β r 2.04 (Notice of Child Abuse, Family Violence or Risk), r 2.10 (filing family violence orders), rr 4.01β4.02 (pre-action compliance and s 60I certificate), rr 10.04β10.05 & r 10.07 (applications for consent orders)
- Family Law (Family Dispute Resolution Practitioners) Regulations 2025 (Cth) β s 20 (assessment of suitability for family dispute resolution), s 22 (suitability of session delivery), s 24 (certificates under s 60I(8))
- State & Territory Breach Provisions β Family Violence Protection Act 2008 (Vic) s 123; Crimes (Domestic and Personal Violence) Act 2007 (NSW) s 14; Domestic and Family Violence Protection Act 2012 (Qld) s 177; Restraining Orders Act 1997 (WA) s 61
- M v M [1988] HCA 68; (1988) 166 CLR 69
- Briginshaw v Briginshaw [1938] HCA 34; (1938) 60 CLR 336
- Neat Holdings Pty Ltd v Karajan Holdings Pty Ltd [1992] HCA 66; (1992) 110 ALR 449; (1992) 67 ALJR 170
- Amador & Amador [2009] FamCAFC 196 at [94]β[96]
- Isles & Nelissen [2022] FedCFamC1A 97
- Bielen & Kozma [2022] FedCFamC1A 221 at [30], [55]
- Dever & Serano [2025] FedCFamC1A 202 at [25], [32]β[34]
Watch
Withholding and supervised access explained
Withholding child without court order
Rights to children exist regardless of allegations
Why you shouldn't forget court proceedings
No court orders and contact rights
Can your ex legally stop contact?
Mother refusing communication about access
Ex withholding child without court order
If you are not seeing your child, act early β the current arrangements can become the status quo.
Already know which process you need?
See separation statistics βFair Dinkum Legal is a document preparation platform, not a law firm. This information is general in nature and does not constitute legal advice.
Read full disclaimer β